On plan recognition and parsing
نویسندگان
چکیده
Probabilistic plan recognition systems based on weighted model counting all work roughly the same way: first they compute the exclusive and exhaustive set of models that explain a given set of observations; next they assign a probability to each model; finally they compute the likelihood of a particular goal by summing the probability of the explanatory models1 in which that goal occurs. In this paper we discuss an optimization for the model-building first step: rather than retain the full tree-like structure of goals which have been partially observed, we can keep only the frontier of as-yet unobserved actions and unachieved subgoals. The system Yappr which we present here uses techniques familiar from parsing algorithms. We give an informal introduction to Yappr in Section 1, a more formal presentation in Section 2, and an analysis of Yappr’s complexity in Section 3. In Section 4 we present experimental result showing the improvement realized from this technique, and then conclude with discussions of the algorithm’s limitations, and future work.
منابع مشابه
Getting Serious About Parsing Plans: A Grammatical Analysis of Plan Recognition
This paper is concerned with making precise the notion that recognizing plans is much like parsing text. To this end, it establishes a correspondence between Kautz’ plan recognition formalism and existing grammatical frameworks. This mapping helps isolate subsets of Kautz’ formalism in which plan recognition can be efficiently performed by parsing. In recent years, plan recognition has emerged ...
متن کاملString Shuffling over a Gap between Parsing and Plan Recognition
We propose a new probabilistic plan recognition algorithm YR based on an extension of Tomita’s Generalized LR (GLR) parser for grammars enriched with the shuffle operator. YR significantly outperforms previous approaches based on topdown parsers, shows more consistent run times among similar libraries, and degrades more gracefully as plan library complexity increases. YR also lifts the restrict...
متن کاملUsing Lexicalized Grammars and Headedness for Approximate Plan Recognition
This paper presents a new algorithm for plan recognition using an action grammar formalism based on Combinatory Catagorial Grammar, that requires a significant shift in thinking about the problem of plan recognition. This approach makes significant use of the concepts of lexicalization and headedness from natural language parsing. It argues that lexicalization of action grammars can help plan r...
متن کاملLexical Ambiguity and its Impact on Plan Recognition for Intrusion Detection
Viewing intrusion detection as a problem of plan recognition presents unique problems. Real world security domains are highly ambiguous and this creates significant problems for plan recognition. This paper distinguishes three sources of ambiguity: action ambiguity, syntactic ambiguity and attachment ambiguity. Previous work in plan recognition has often conflated these different sources of amb...
متن کاملOn Natural Language Processing and Plan Recognition
The research areas of plan recognition and natural language parsing share many common features and even algorithms. However, the dialog between these two disciplines has not been effective. Specifically, significant recent results in parsing mildly context sensitive grammars have not been leveraged in the state of the art plan recognition systems. This paper will outline the relations between n...
متن کاملConsidering State in Plan Recognition with Lexicalized Grammars
This paper documents extending the ELEXIR (Engine for LEXicalized Intent Recognition) system (Geib 2009; Geib and Goldman 2011) with a world model. This is a significant increase in the expressiveness of the plan recognition system and allows a number of additions to the algorithm, most significantly conditioning probabilities for recognized plans on the state of the world during execution. Sin...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2009